Age of Wonders II Heaven Julia with Gameplay background
Welcome
Downloads Home
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
Scenarios
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » Scenarios » Lord of the Rings

Download File Post Review Post Comment

Lord of the Rings

Author File Description
the_nihilist
File Details
Ruleset: AoW2: TWT - TS Standard Rules
Map Size: XL
Levels: 2
Single Player?: Yes
Co-Op vs. AI?: Yes
PBEM/Hotseat?: Yes
Multiplayer Online?: Yes
# of Wizards: 8
# of players: 8
Skill Level: Any (depends on AI difficulty setting)
Password Protected: No
Tolkien's Middle Earth.

By Magnus & Sune Nilaus Olsen (& Tue).

We were actually the first persons to do a Middle-earth scenario, we just didn't submit it

in time. Really we were. Honest.

But anyway it is the best map because we have based it on thorough studies of Tolkien's works

and "Tolkien's Guide to Middle-earth" by Robert Foster and the "Dictionary of the languages of Tolkien's

Middle-earth" by a bunch of students. Oh and the twelve volumes of Tolkien's Notes published

posthumously by his son Christopher Tolkien.

Completed on 8/9 2002.

PS: Don't be the dwarves. They suck.
AuthorReviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Galahad_2nd
Rating
3.6
Breakdown
Playability1.0
Balance3.0
Creativity5.0
Map Design5.0
Story/Instructions4.0
Playability: 1
The designers obviously spent a lot more time with research and design than they did with play-testing. This map is very slow and difficult to play: not only is it an eight-wizard XL map, but everybody has huge numbers of units and heroes, the rivers are impassible obstacles with few crossings, and Gandalf moves too slowly. I could only get through a few turns. If the playability is improved, this could be a great map.

Balance: 3
This is listed as both a Multiplayer map and a Single Player map, not a good idea. I think that it is more balanced as a single-player map, but I could only play a few turns so I'm not really sure.

Creativity: 5
The designers have a new and different approach to making a Middle-Earth map, making a real effort to simulate the War of the Ring rather just a multi-player map of the general arrangement of the lands of Middle Earth. I really like having the heroes of the Fellowship including Gandalf start out from Rivendell, with the same player controlling Gondor -- it has the promise of a good single-player game of Lord of the Rings.

Map Design: 5
Very well researched and beautifully done.

Story/Instructions: 4
We all know the story so it is OK but could use more events, signs, etc.


Additional Comments:
I already posted lots of comments previously. (Hope they don't get erased when I post this!)
I Always WinCOC
Rating
1.8
Breakdown
Playability1.0
Balance2.0
Creativity2.0
Map Design1.0
Story/Instructions3.0
Playability: 1
Gandalf is too slow, way too many units, like a few other people have said, Gondor (gandalf) is too strong, he is almost as good as mordor and has more cities and heros
Balance: 2
Sauron and Mouth of Sauron should be combined big time and Gondor should be a seperate wizard not gandalf, he doesnt own Gondor
Creativity: 2
Lots of LOTR maps anywayz, so this is nothing new

Map Design: 1
Ur research should also include the books, and not just the movies, Use more grass, there is grass in ME. also, Osgiliath is on an island, Minas Tirith, then 2 bridges to Osgiliath, and then 2 bridges to Minas Ithil, or Morgul as known in LOTR. Ithilien is WAY WAY WAY WAY to big, and should be on the river side of minas morgul, and some of it should be destroyed. Fangorn should not be dead forest, it is the opposite of a dead forest. and there should be a few area guards of earth elementals there.
Story/Instructions: 3
i gave u a 3 because i love LOTR and ME, thats about it.

Additional Comments:
The ring is way way way way way way way way to powerful, frodo could take out sauron with the ring, thats crap. it should have no stats at all, and if sauron or saruman get the ring, the game should end.
Pickle, please make ME2.00 this is 1 of the worse ME maps out. The 2nd age map is the best in my opinion
petis
Rating
1.0
Breakdown
Playability1.0
Balance1.0
Creativity1.0
Map Design1.0
Story/Instructions1.0
Playability: 1

Balance: 1
*the map is not very balanced (to play for Elrond is boring-nothing is happening (to as by humans))

Creativity: 1
*Moria is too small - you should work more on it

Map Design: 1
*the map is empty, you fell like on an desert
*no events, low elevation effects
*the main geography isnt right (Rivendell is next to Lorien, acces to Moria is under Lorien, Grey Havens are on the other site of Luna...)
*so many things are missing (like the Lonely mountain)

Story/Instructions: 1
*Durin's Bane or Balrog wasnt a friend of orcs and he also wasnt under Saurons control
*where are the 3 ways in Moria (this Moria has no similarities to Tolkiens Moria (except the name))
*there are so many mistakes on this map, i can write letters about it...

Additional Comments:
its clear that the cretor of this map has no knowlage about Tolkiens Lord of the Rings, its history and geography... And talk something in the way this is the best Lotr map ever:( I had to puch your ratting down

[Edited on 11/10/04 @ 04:25 PM]


Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
2.1
Breakdown
Playability1.0
Balance2.0
Creativity2.7
Map Design2.3
Story/Instructions2.7
Statistics
Downloads:4,248
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:493.94 KB
Added:01/18/03