There are not enough towns and a lot of area guards. This is especially a probelm for the AI. Apart from that, this map is okay.
This is good. Some players have better positions than others, but no position is unfair.
Solid, but nothing really new. Some new heroes.
Map Design: 4
The overworld is sometimes a bit boring, but many areas look interesting. The underground is confusing. That's how I like it.
Add some more mountains, rivers, lakes or other obstacles and your map will be much better.
A lot of strange messenges. Maybe I just did not get it right.
This is not a bad map. Improve it a bit, and it will be a really good one.