This is my first map and I was pretty much screwing around with the editor and came up with this. It's only about 5 hours work and is really wierd so let me know how crappy it is.
Playability: 1
Needs a lot of work to be interesting enough to be worth playing. I played as tigrans, but their capital is on wasteland, the terrain is flat and undecorated, and the plain black borders onto bright white forest - totally unconvincing and uninteresting
Balance: 1
No attempt at balancing
Creativity: 1
Random generator maps are more interesting
Map Design: 1
Needs a lot more work
Story/Instructions: 1
No story or instructions
Additional Comments:
I suggest you use a random map as the basis for your next effort, that way a lot of the groundwork is already done for you