Playability: 4
Lots of treasurers and minor quests.
Balance: 4
Strong central AI controlled opponent takes awhile to take out. As is the other players shouldn't really need to ally though.
Creativity: 4
Some very pretty areas on the map and some surprising events.
Map Design: 5
A very nice layout with interesting areas.
Story/Instructions: 3
More then many, but you can tell it just never got tied together into a conhesive plot.
Additional Comments:
Even though not complete, mostly evident by lack of continuity of the events and special places to build the story it is still a nice SP map.